What should a team member say in a one-on-one?

Dongyoung Kim, CPO

A one-on-one is the team member's time. Three things are enough to prepare: one or two topics you really want to discuss, one line on what you want from your manager, and progress on the promises from your last one-on-one. In the conversation, talk about where you're stuck and what you need rather than reporting on work, and before you finish, confirm once more who will do what.

Why is a one-on-one the team member's time?

This article is for team members with a one-on-one coming up. Leaders and HR who want to introduce one-on-ones to their teams are welcome to share it as is.

Andy Grove, former CEO of Intel, wrote in High Output Management that a one-on-one should be regarded as the subordinate's meeting, with its agenda and tone set by them. When the manager sets the agenda, the one-on-one soon turns into a status check. When the team member brings the topics, the manager knows right away what to help with.

So team members who get the most from one-on-ones think first about “what do I want to take away this time,” not “what am I going to hear.” If you want to know what a one-on-one is first, see What is a one-on-one (1on1)?.

Three things to prepare before a one-on-one

Ten minutes the day before is enough. Share what you write with your manager in advance, so they can prepare answers too.

1. One or two topics

If nothing comes to mind, look back over the past two weeks and write down three things: what took the most time, where you got most stuck, and what weighed on you most. Pick the one that needs your manager to resolve, and that's your topic.

2. One line on what you want from your manager

The same topic goes differently depending on what you want. Say up front which of these five you need.

  • A decision: “I'd like you to choose between option A and option B.”
  • Information: “I'd like to know why this project's priority changed.”
  • Support: “I'd like you to ask the other team for their help.”
  • Feedback: “I'd like to hear what I could have done better in my last presentation.”
  • To be heard: “I'd like to share the situation before we look for solutions.”

3. Progress on last time's promises

Write one line for each thing agreed at the last one-on-one, including what your manager said they would do, not just your own items. How to set and follow up promises is covered in detail in How do you set and follow up one-on-one action items?.

When you share in advance, you can use these four lines as they are.

  • What I want to talk about this time:
  • What I'd like from you: (decision / information / support / feedback / to be heard)
  • Progress on last time's promises:
  • How I'm doing lately (1-5):

30 questions to ask your manager

Two or three questions at a time is plenty. Pick from the group that matches what's on your mind lately.

Aligning priorities and expectations

  1. Of the work I'm handling, what matters most right now?
  2. What results this quarter would you see as doing well?
  3. Is there anything I'm doing that I could do less of, or stop?
  4. How far can I decide on this myself, and from what point should I ask you?
  5. If we had to choose between schedule and quality on this project, which matters more?
  6. From where you sit, is my workload about right these days?

Getting feedback

  1. Could you name one thing I did well and one thing I could improve over the last month?
  2. Did my explanation land in the last meeting?
  3. What way of working would you like me to keep doing?
  4. Have you heard anything from other teams about my work?
  5. What should I change first to get to the next level?
  6. What could I do differently to help you better?

Growth and career

  1. What experience would help me be better a year from now?
  2. What do you see as my strengths, and where could I use them more?
  3. What criteria do I need to meet to move to the next role?
  4. There's something new I'd like to take on. How should I prepare?
  5. When you were at my stage, what do you think you did best?
  6. There's an area I want to learn. Are there opportunities for that here?

Understanding team and company direction

  1. What's the team's biggest goal this quarter, and where does my work fit?
  2. There's a recent company decision I'd like to understand better. Could you explain the background?
  3. What problem are you thinking about most these days?
  4. What will our team do more of next year, and less of?
  5. What does senior leadership expect most from our team?
  6. Is there anything going on with other teams that I should know?

Aligning on ways of working

  1. How and how often do you prefer to get updates?
  2. If something urgent comes up, which channel should I use to reach you?
  3. When it's hard for me to judge something alone, when should I ask you for help?
  4. Is there anything about the format or cadence of our one-on-ones we should change?
  5. When I disagree with a colleague, how would you like us to sort it out?
  6. What's the one thing you'd most like from me?

If you'd like to go deeper on your career, suggest the three-stage flow in How do you hold a career conversation in a one-on-one? to your manager.

How to bring up difficult topics

Uncomfortable topics are easier to raise in the order of facts, impact, and what you'd like. You don't have to hide your feelings, but keep the focus on the situation rather than the person.

SituationTry saying
Too much work“I'm on three projects right now and working late every week. At this rate, quality will slip on next month's deadline. I'd like us to decide together which of the three comes first.”
Trouble working with a colleague“In the last two reviews, feedback came the day before the deadline, so I pushed the schedule back twice. Before I talk to them directly, I'd like your advice on how to approach it.”
Feedback or a review that doesn't make sense to you“In your last feedback you said I lacked initiative. I'd like to know specifically which moments made you feel that way, so I know what to change next time.”
Wanting to try different work“I've learned a lot in my current work, and next I'd like to do something closer to customers. Even if it's not right away, I'd like to ask what preparation would open up that chance.”
Feeling worn out“I'm at about a 2 out of 5 lately. I think the cause is the schedule changing all the time. Rather than jumping to a solution, I wanted to let you know where things stand first.”

Three things for team members to avoid in one-on-ones

  • Spending the whole time on status updates: share progress in writing beforehand, and talk only about what's stuck in the one-on-one.
  • Ending with “Nothing much”: if nothing's up, bring one question about growth or team direction. Those are the days to ask your manager something that takes time.
  • Ending without promises: in the last five minutes, confirm: “I understand that I'll do this, and you'll do that. Is that right?”

What leaders and HR can do: make room for team members to speak

Whether team members come prepared depends on how the leader opens the space. When you start, make clear whether one-on-ones are evaluations and who sees the notes. How to explain this is in How do you introduce one-on-ones to your team?. For the leader's own preparation, see How do you prepare for a one-on-one?.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q.What if I have nothing to talk about in a one-on-one?
Having nothing to say often just means nothing is stuck right now. On those days, bring one question about growth or team direction. It's a good day for the questions above that need a longer conversation, like the growth and career or team and company direction groups.
Q.Can I bring up complaints about my manager in a one-on-one?
Yes. One-on-ones are for topics that are hard to raise in team meetings. But rather than only complaining, saying the facts, the impact, and what you'd like together helps your manager know what to do.
Q.Does what I say in one-on-ones affect my review?
It depends on the company. Many companies keep one-on-ones separate from review meetings. If you're worried, ask in your first one-on-one: “Who sees the notes, and are they used in reviews?” The difference between the two is covered in How is a one-on-one different from a performance review?.
Q.How much should I prepare for a one-on-one?
Ten minutes the day before is enough. Write just one or two topics, one line on what you'd like, and progress on last time's promises, and send it to your manager in advance.
Q.Can I talk about pay or compensation in a one-on-one?
Yes. But your direct manager often doesn't have the final say. Checking the process first, as in “What's the process for this, and who should I talk to?”, keeps the conversation realistic.

ORBLIT

How Orblit helps

To make it easier to put this article into practice, Orblit helps in these ways.

  • 01Team members set the agenda first

    Team members write a prep before the meeting, with a prep chatbot helping them get ready by chat. The leader prepares questions based on that prep.

  • 02Notes you write together

    Leader and team member leave notes in a shared meeting note they can edit at the same time, and the progress of action items carries into the next meeting's prep.

  • 03Promises both of you can see

    Record the conversation and AI organizes a summary and each person's action items, so both of you see the same list of who will do what.

Sources

  1. High Output Management · Andrew S. Grove

Read next

What is a one-on-one (1on1)?

A one-on-one (1on1) is a formal, two-way conversation in which a leader and a team member meet one-to-one at a set time to talk about work and growth. Unlike a status report or a casual lunch chat, it has a set time and purpose, and the leader listens to the team member instead of simply giving instructions. It repeats on a short cycle of roughly one week to one month rather than twice a year or once a year, and it focuses on managing the process and supporting growth rather than on results.

Dongyoung Kim, CPO

How do you set and follow up one-on-one action items?

A one-on-one action item is the next step agreed at the end of the conversation, and one sentence should say who will do what by when. Set only one or two per one-on-one, and write down what the leader will do as well as the team member. Then spend the first five minutes of the next one-on-one checking last time's action items. Keep to these three and you will have far fewer “same conversation every time” one-on-ones.

Dongyoung Kim, CPO

How do you hold a career conversation in a one-on-one?

A career one-on-one is a conversation in which you and a team member work out what they want to do and how they want to grow. Rather than asking everything at once, split it into three conversations: the past (what choices they have made), the future (where they want to get to), and the present (what to do now). End with an action plan that has owners and deadlines, and check it in regular one-on-ones.

Dongyoung Kim, CPO