How do you prepare for a one-on-one?
Dongyoung Kim, CPO
Before the meeting, look back at the action items and notes from the last one-on-one, check the topics the team member added, then settle on one or two topics of your own and one question you must ask today. The team member's topics are the center of the agenda; the leader's job is to get ready to listen to them well. Below are a ten-minute checklist, a sample 30-minute agenda, and how to ask the team member to prepare.
Why prepare for one-on-ones
A one-on-one you walk into unprepared usually drifts into the leader asking about whatever work progress is on their mind. The team member just reports and leaves, and comes to see the next one-on-one as one more status meeting.
How satisfied leaders feel also differs from what team members experience. When meeting researcher Steven Rogelberg surveyed 250 direct reports, nearly half rated their 1:1s as suboptimal (HBR, 2022), and managers tend to overestimate how effective their 1:1s are (Ohio State Fisher, 2025). His advice is to treat the 1:1 as primarily for the employee. A short preparation is the easiest way to keep to that.
A leader's ten-minute one-on-one prep checklist
| Time | What to do | Question to ask yourself |
|---|---|---|
| 0-2 min | Check last time's action items | Did I do what I said I would? How far along are the team member's? |
| 2-4 min | Reread notes from the last conversation | What were they worried about? What did we say we'd come back to? |
| 4-6 min | Look back over the last two weeks of work | What went well, what got stuck, any unusual signals? |
| 6-8 min | Check the team member's topics; settle one or two of your own | Is there a decision or feedback I must pass on this time? |
| 8-10 min | Pick one question to ask today | What do I most want to hear from this person right now? |
The first two rows matter most. Just seeing that the leader remembers last time's promises tells the team member this is an ongoing conversation. For the last row, pick just one question that fits the person's situation, like these.
- A team member with too much on their plate: “Is there anything you're working on that could wait until next week, or be dropped?”
- A team member in a new role: “What has been most different from what you expected in the new work?”
- A team member performing well: “Is there something you'd like to do more of next quarter?”
Sample one-on-one agenda (30 minutes)
| Time | Item | Who leads |
|---|---|---|
| 0-5 min | Catching up and last time's action items | Leader |
| 5-20 min | Topics the team member brought | Team member |
| 20-25 min | Leader's topics (updates, feedback, requests) | Leader |
| 25-30 min | What we agreed and the next action items | Together |
Written out, it looks like this.
| [11/20 one-on-one] Team lead Kim – Lee | Contents |
|---|---|
| Last time's action items | (Team member) Share draft customer-interview questions (Team lead) Report back on the schedule agreed with the design team |
| Team member's topics | Whether we can cut next month's launch scope Advice on taking a data analysis course |
| Team lead's topics | Feedback on how last week's review meeting was run |
| Question to ask today | “What's the hardest part of your work these days?” |
To settle on a format for the agenda as a team, see How do you structure a one-on-one doc?. The flow on the day itself is covered in How do you run a one-on-one (1on1)?.
How to ask the team member to prepare
It's best when the team member fills in the agenda first. But “Bring your topics” alone leaves them unsure what to write. Try sending a message like this the day before.
“Before our one-on-one at 2 tomorrow, could you jot down two or three things you'd like to talk about? They don't have to be about work. If nothing comes to mind, you can answer one of these three questions instead.”
- What's stuck or needs a decision lately?
- What went best, and what didn't go so well, over the past two weeks?
- What would you like me to help with, or stop doing?
If the team member rarely brings topics or tends to hold back in one-on-ones, see also What should you do when a team member won't talk in a one-on-one?.
What to prepare in particular situations
| Situation | What to prepare in addition |
|---|---|
| First one-on-one | Get-to-know-you questions, and explain how one-on-ones will run (cadence, who sees the notes). See new manager one-on-ones |
| When there's a performance issue | Write down what you observed and the result you expected. Keep it apart from review talk. See one-on-one feedback |
| When the team member seems worn out | Cut work topics and leave more time to ask about workload and how they're doing |
| After a long gap | Skim what has changed (projects, organization, personal circumstances) and start by sorting out the status of past promises |
| When a career conversation is planned | Send questions to think about in advance, and find out what opportunities (projects, training) you can offer. See career one-on-ones |
When preparing feels like a burden: notes make it shorter
With more than five team members, it's easy to skip this preparation week after week. The surest way to cut prep time is to keep notes in the same place every time. If action items are written with an owner and a deadline, the first two rows of the checklist take under a minute. How to write action items is covered in How do you set and follow up one-on-one action items?.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Q.Who should set the one-on-one agenda?
- We recommend the team member sets it first and the leader adds to it. The one-on-one is the team member's time, so spend at least half of it on their topics and keep yours to one or two.
- Q.How much time should one-on-one prep take?
- About ten minutes each time is enough. Take a little longer before a first one-on-one, a career conversation, or difficult feedback; prep gets shorter as notes build up.
- Q.How far in advance should topics be shared?
- Writing them down by the day before gives both of you time to think. When the leader brings a sensitive topic such as feedback, sharing at least the subject in advance keeps the team member from feeling ambushed.
- Q.What if the team member doesn't bring any topics?
- Rather than blaming the blank space, give them three easy-to-answer questions in advance. Once they have seen the leader actually take up and act on their topics a few times, topics come more naturally.
- Q.Can we use the same agenda format every time?
- Yes. A consistent structure actually makes it easier to compare with past notes. But repeating the same questions every time turns it into a formality, so change the “question to ask today” each time.
ORBLIT
How Orblit helps
To make it easier to put this article into practice, Orblit helps in these ways.
01Last time's promises on the prep screen
Record the conversation and AI organizes a summary and action items; past action items and suggested topics for the next 1on1 carry over into preparing the next one-on-one, so the first two rows of the checklist are done on one screen.
02A question to ask today
Based on the prep the team member wrote and past records, Orblit AI suggests questions for each team member.
03Don't miss the day to prepare
Orblit works with Google Calendar and Google Meet, and once you set a one-on-one cycle it keeps track of recurring meetings with email and push notifications.
Sources
- Make the Most of Your One-on-One Meetings · Harvard Business Review (Steven G. Rogelberg) · 2022-11
- Glad We Met: The Art and Science of 1:1 Meetings · Ohio State University Fisher College of Business (Richard Batts) · 2025-08-14
