How do you give feedback in a one-on-one?
Dongyoung Kim, CPO
Give one-on-one feedback by saying specifically when it happened, what the behavior was, and what impact it had, then asking the team member why they did it. It's not a place to announce a verdict but a conversation that takes one observed fact and decides the next step together. Praise needs the same specific structure if you want the good behavior repeated. Below are the structure, sample dialogues, and the order for raising feedback within a one-on-one.
Why one-on-ones are a good place for feedback
Feedback is most useful close to the behavior. Bring up something from three months ago in a half-year or year-end review, and the team member barely remembers it and the chance to fix it is long gone. In one-on-ones every one or two weeks, you can talk about it within two weeks at most. The difference between the two is covered in How is a one-on-one different from a performance review?.
How often feedback happens is tied to engagement, too. According to Gallup, 80% of employees who said they received meaningful feedback in the past week were fully engaged. Conversations of 15 to 30 minutes had a greater impact than 30- to 60-minute ones when they happened regularly, and only 16% said their last conversation with their manager was extremely meaningful (Gallup, 2023). Short, frequent, and specific is the key.
The basic structure of one-on-one feedback: SBI-I
SBI is a feedback model developed by the Center for Creative Leadership (CCL): you describe the Situation, the Behavior, and its Impact in turn. CCL suggests adding a step that asks about the Intent behind the behavior (SBI-I), turning one-way delivery into a two-way conversation (Mind Tools). That fourth step fits one-on-ones especially well.
| Step | What you say | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Situation | When and where | “In last Thursday's weekly meeting with the client.” |
| Behavior | One behavior you saw yourself | “When you were asked a question, you started with where the data came from.” |
| Impact | The result for you, the team, or the customer | “The client didn't ask for the material again, so we moved straight on to the next item.” |
| Intent | Ask why they did it | “Was there a reason you prepared it that way?” |
In the behavior step, leave out words that judge character or attitude. “Thorough” and “irresponsible” are judgments; “named the source first” and “didn't share anything until the day before the deadline” are observations. For impact, make yourself the subject, as in “From where I sat” or “For the team,” and you get explanation back instead of rebuttal.
Examples of praise
Praise that ends at “Good job” leaves nothing to repeat. Point to the behavior you want to see again.
Situation 1. A team member who helped a new hire
| Dialogue | |
|---|---|
| Leader | This week you wrote up the release process and sent it to Minsu, who just joined. Thanks to that he did his first release on his own, and I didn't have to explain the same thing again. What made you write that document? |
| Team member | That was what frustrated me most when I joined. |
| Leader | How about putting it on the team wiki as a standard onboarding document? |
Situation 2. A team member who raised a hard problem early
| Dialogue | |
|---|---|
| Leader | Because you told me last Tuesday that the schedule was likely to slip, we could rearrange it with the client in advance. Hearing bad news early helps me more than anything. |
When you acknowledge someone for bringing unwelcome news, as in the second example, they raise problems early the next time too.
Examples of improvement feedback
Handle one piece of improvement feedback at a time, and once you've said it, let the team member do more of the talking.
Situation 1. A delay reported on the due date
| Dialogue | |
|---|---|
| Leader | I found out Friday afternoon that the proposal draft due Friday was delayed, so we had to ask the client to change the schedule the same day. I'd like to hear first what was going on. |
| Team member | I was worried from Wednesday, but I thought I could make it if I kept going. |
| Leader | I understand wanting to see it through. From now on, if you see a risk two days before a deadline, could you share even one line? What way would be easiest for you? |
Situation 2. Often interrupting colleagues in meetings
| Dialogue | |
|---|---|
| Leader | In yesterday's planning review you cut in twice while Jiwon was explaining and proposed a different option. After that I noticed Jiwon held back for the rest of the meeting. What was on your mind then? |
In both examples the leader doesn't decide the fix first but asks the team member how. More on asking so the team member finds their own answer is in How do you coach in a one-on-one?.
Five steps for raising feedback in a one-on-one
- Put it on the agenda in advance. Even just “I'd like to talk briefly about last week's proposal schedule” keeps the team member from feeling ambushed.
- Hear the team member out first. The one-on-one is their time. Raise feedback in the middle or later, after their topics.
- Say one thing, using SBI. Say three things in one sitting and they won't properly remember any of them.
- Ask about intent and listen. If circumstances you didn't know come out, you may revise the feedback. Talk less at this step.
- Agree on the next action and when to check. Write it down, like “share two days before the deadline, starting with the next proposal,” and check early in the next one-on-one. How to set action items is covered in How do you set and follow up one-on-one action items?.
When you see a change at the next one-on-one, give it back as praise. Improvement feedback that ends in acknowledgment is remembered as help. For putting feedback on the agenda ahead of time, see How do you prepare for a one-on-one?.
Common mistakes in one-on-one feedback
- The praise-criticism-praise sandwich: the point gets buried. Give praise and improvement separately, and specifically.
- Feedback based on hearsay: “Everyone feels that way” makes people defensive. Talk only about behavior you saw yourself.
- Mixing it with review results: hint at a rating in a one-on-one and the team member starts choosing their words. Prepare review-result conversations separately.
- Not writing it down: if you don't record the feedback and the agreed action, you end up repeating the same conversation.
Questions to get feedback from your team member
When feedback only flows one way, one-on-ones feel like inspections. When the leader asks for feedback first, team members take feedback more easily too. Ask one of these once a month.
- “What's one thing you'd like me to do more of lately, and one thing less?”
- “Was there a moment last month when I really helped, or actually got in the way?”
- “Is there anything about the way I give feedback that I should change?”
More questions are collected in What questions should you ask in a one-on-one?.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Q.Do I need to give feedback in every one-on-one?
- You don't need to prepare improvement feedback every time. But it's good to mention one behavior you've observed since you last met, whether praise or improvement. On days with no fitting feedback, ask the team member for feedback on you.
- Q.Should improvement feedback be given in a separate meeting instead of the one-on-one?
- Unless it's urgent or serious, the one-on-one is fine. Giving feedback often in a set place keeps it from becoming a special event. Anything that immediately affects safety or customers shouldn't wait for the next one-on-one; say it right away.
- Q.What if the team member pushes back on the feedback?
- Treat pushback as a chance to hear their intent. Ask, “Could you tell me more about what was going on?” and if there were circumstances you didn't know, acknowledge them on the spot. On the observed behavior and its impact, go back over the facts and look for common ground.
- Q.Should praise be public and improvement feedback private?
- Improvement feedback belongs in a private setting like a one-on-one. Praise worth sharing with the whole team can be public, but in the one-on-one say more specifically why the behavior was good. Some people are uncomfortable with public praise, so ask about their preference in a one-on-one first.
- Q.What should I watch for when giving feedback in a video one-on-one?
- Faces and reactions are hard to read, so check in words after the feedback: “Could you tell me how that came across?” Keep your camera on, and confirm the agreed action together in writing before you finish. More in How do you run remote one-on-one meetings?.
ORBLIT
How Orblit helps
To make it easier to put this article into practice, Orblit helps in these ways.
01Feedback carries into the next one-on-one
Record the conversation and AI organizes a summary and action items, and the prep screen for the next one-on-one shows last time's promises again, so you can check the change right away.
02Did you talk too much while giving feedback?
AI leadership coaching shows the speaking ratio of leader and team member, and analyzes what the leader said to point out strengths and areas to improve.
03Recordings are not kept
Recordings are deleted automatically within three days after analysis, and meeting data is not used to train AI models.
Sources
- A Great Manager's Most Important Habit · Gallup · 2023-05-29
- The Situation-Behavior-Impact Feedback Tool · Mind Tools
