How do you open a one-on-one?

Dongyoung Kim, CPO

A one-on-one icebreaker isn't about finding more fun questions; it's about opening the first three to five minutes with a question the team member can answer easily. A good first question can be answered briefly, has no right answer, and leads naturally into the main conversation. Choose it to fit the team member's state and the context of your last conversation.

Why one-on-ones need an icebreaker

For the full flow of a one-on-one, see How do you run a one-on-one (1on1)?, and for questions for the main part, What questions should you ask in a one-on-one?. This article focuses on the few minutes before that, which open the conversation.

A one-on-one runs in a different mode from everyday exchanges of instructions and updates. If the leader sits down and starts with “How's that thing going?”, the team member switches into reporting mode and the conversation easily ends as a status check. One opening question signals that this time is theirs.

Three marks of a good icebreaker question

  1. It's easy to answer. It should be fine to answer in a sentence or two. “What's your life goal these days?” is too heavy to open with.
  2. It doesn't sound like an evaluation. Questions that ask for a score, like “How satisfied are you with work this week, out of 10?”, create tension from the start. If you do ask for a score, make clear you want to hear the reason.
  3. It leads into the main topic. Ten minutes on the weather is not an icebreaker but wasted time. The best questions have answers that lead naturally to “Shall we talk about that today?”

40 one-on-one icebreaker questions by situation

Checking in on how they're doing (8)

  1. If you described this week in one word, what would it be?
  2. Out of 10, how's your energy these days? I'm more curious about the reason than the number.
  3. What's stuck with you most since our last one-on-one?
  4. What do you usually do to unwind after work lately?
  5. Is there one thing this week where you thought, “I did that well”?
  6. Is work on the heavy side lately, or manageable?
  7. What did you do over the weekend? Was it restful?
  8. How are you feeling coming into this time today?

Starting naturally from recent work (8)

  1. What's the most interesting part of your work right now?
  2. And what drains you the most?
  3. Did anything take longer than expected this week?
  4. Is there something you learned recently that stuck with you?
  5. Who's been great to work with lately?
  6. Is there anything about your current project I probably don't know?
  7. Is there a thought about work that's been on your mind all week?
  8. What are you most looking forward to, or worried about, next week?

First one-on-one, or still getting to know each other (7)

  1. Of the leaders you've worked with, what made the easiest ones easy to work with?
  2. How do you like to get feedback: right away, or saved up?
  3. Do you prefer messaging, or talking in person?
  4. When work has gone well for you, what was usually going on?
  5. Is there a sign I could notice when you're not doing well?
  6. Is there anything outside work you've been into lately?
  7. How could we use this time so it's helpful for you?

When the mood is heavy or times are hard (6)

  1. You seem really busy lately. What feels heaviest right now?
  2. We can start with something other than work today if you'd like. How does that sound?
  3. If you could take one thing off your plate, what would it be?
  4. If there's one thing I could help with this week, what would it be?
  5. How have you been feeling since what happened last time?
  6. How much would you like to talk about today? It's fine to keep it short.

If signs of exhaustion have lasted for weeks, see also How do you run a one-on-one with a burned-out team member?.

Meeting over video (5)

  1. Where are you working from today? Is it a good setup?
  2. What does your daily rhythm look like when you work from home?
  3. Is there information you feel you're missing working on your own?
  4. Could you tell me about what's behind you (a book, an object)?
  5. If there's a topic that's awkward to discuss over video, we can meet separately next time. What works for today?

Running video one-on-ones overall is covered in How do you run remote one-on-one meetings?.

When one-on-ones feel the same every time (6)

  1. How do our one-on-ones feel to you lately? Is there anything you'd change?
  2. Of our last few one-on-ones, which conversation helped most?
  3. Is there a question you feel I've never asked you?
  4. Have you read or watched anything lately that helped with work?
  5. Looking back from six months from now, what would you like to have been doing?
  6. Would you like to set today's agenda instead of me?

Using the same question every time turns it into a formality. Note which questions you've used and rotate them.

Moving from the icebreaker to the main topic

Three to five minutes is enough for an icebreaker. The most natural move is to pick up a word from the team member's answer and use it to lead into the main topic.

Team member's answerLeader's transition
“This week was ‘chaos.’”“Let's look together at what made it chaotic today, and whether there's something we can take off your plate.”
“Data analysis is the most fun lately.”“Then shall we also talk today about how you could do more of it?”
“Nothing in particular.”“Then I'll start with the topics I brought. Jump in anytime if something comes to mind.”
“Things were a bit tough with a partner team.”“Let's start there. Tell me what happened from the beginning.”

If “Nothing in particular” keeps coming up, the issue is more likely trust and preparation than the question. See What should you do when a team member won't talk in a one-on-one?.

Icebreaker questions to avoid

  • Questions that pry into private life: dating, marriage, family plans, health, religion or politics. Don't ask unless the team member brought it up first.
  • Questions with a set answer: something like “It's going fine, right?”, which can only be answered “yes,” closes the conversation.
  • Questions that end in the leader's own story: spend five minutes on “Good weekend? Mine was…” and the team member's time shrinks.
  • Questions that grill them about the day's work: “Why was yesterday's report late?” isn't an icebreaker; it's a check.

Good opening questions come from remembering the last conversation. “How did the presentation you mentioned go?” beats any list of questions. How to skim the last conversation beforehand is in How do you prepare for a one-on-one?.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q.How long should a one-on-one icebreaker take?
For a 30-minute one-on-one, three to five minutes is enough. If the team member carries on with a long story of their own, that may be the day's main topic, so don't cut it off.
Q.Do I need an icebreaker every time?
It doesn't have to be a set question. But a short check-in like “How are you today?” is good every time. It stops the habit of jumping straight into work.
Q.What questions work with new hires or people I've just met?
Questions about how they like to work. The feedback and communication questions in the “First one-on-one, or still getting to know each other” group give answers you'll use in every one-on-one afterward. If you've just become a team lead, see also How should a new manager start one-on-ones?.
Q.What if the team member finds icebreakers awkward?
No need to force it. Say “Let's go straight to today's topic,” and at the end ask, “How would you like us to start next time?”

ORBLIT

How Orblit helps

To make it easier to put this article into practice, Orblit helps in these ways.

  • 01Opening lines from your last conversation

    Orblit suggests tailored questions based on the team member's prep and one-on-one history, and a member guide suggests how to steer the conversation based on their prep and tendencies.

  • 02A starting point for next time

    Record the conversation and AI organizes a summary and action items, which lead into suggested topics for the next 1on1, so the next opening question is easier to prepare.

  • 03Video one-on-ones too

    Orblit works with Google Meet and Google Calendar, so one-on-ones over video are recorded and tracked in the same flow.

Read next

What questions should you ask in a one-on-one?

Pick one or two one-on-one questions from five topics: wellbeing, work, growth, feedback, and team. Rather than asking everything at once, start with the topic the team member most wants to discuss, and after hearing the answer add a question that leads to a next step, such as "What support would help?" The questions below are examples compiled by Orblit.

Dongyoung Kim, CPO

How do you run a one-on-one (1on1)?

Fix the schedule, have the team member write their topics in advance, and after the conversation record what you agreed so you can check it at the next meeting. If you are new to one-on-ones, start with 30 minutes every two weeks, then adjusting the cadence and length to how familiar each person is with their current work. What matters most is that the meeting is not canceled and keeps a predictable rhythm.

Dongyoung Kim, CPO

What should you do when a team member won't talk in a one-on-one?

When a team member holds back in one-on-ones, the reason usually lies more in the setting than in their personality. Most likely they don't trust that it's safe to speak, don't know what the one-on-one is for, or the leader is taking up most of the conversation. So before asking more questions, diagnose the cause, cut down how much you talk, and share the agenda in advance so the team member can think ahead.

Dongyoung Kim, CPO